Kuldeep Yadav vs R Ashwin - (Source : AFP)
On Sunday, October 12, Kuldeep Yadav, yet again, weaved his magic with the ball and picked up his fifth five-wicket haul to rattle Windies for just 248 runs in the first innings of the 2nd Test. Yadav has been on a roll in this series as the left-arm spinner has taken nine wickets in just three innings.
Notably, since the retirement of R Ashwin , the management is touting Kuldeep as India's premier spinner even in red-ball cricket. The left-arm spinner was always the first choice in white-ball cricket, but recently, he has been getting his chances in Test cricket.
Further, Kuldeep is making full use of the opportunities presented to him and has repaid the faith shown in him by the selectors. The fans have often pointed out the injustice towards Kuldeep, as the spinner has played just 15 matches in 8 years since his debut.
Meanwhile, this article will shed light on Kuldeep's performance against R Ashwin after the first 15 Test matches.
Kuldeep Yadav vs R Ashwin: Who is the better bowler after 15 Tests R Ashwin made his India Test debut in 2011 and played 15 Tests within just three years of his debut, unlike Kuldeep, who had to wait for eight years to cement his place in the team. Let's look at his detailed stats after 15 Tests.
CriteriaSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
Kuldeep YadavSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
R Ashwin Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
TestsSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 15Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 15Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table WicketsSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 65Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 85Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Overs BowledSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 390Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 854Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table AverageSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 21.09Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 29.56Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table EconomySelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 3.51Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 2.94Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Strike-rateSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 36Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 60.42Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 5w/10wSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 5Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 8/0Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
Key Observation If we look at the stats, then R Ashwin has taken 20 more wickets than Kuldeep Yadav after 15 Tests and also boasts more five-wicket hauls. While, Kuldeep has five, Ashwin had eight, which signifies that the team was really depended on the right-arm off-spinner to get the job done and pick up wickets in bunches. However, if we look at the strike-rate, which is a crucial parameter for any bowler, then there is a massive difference. Kuldeep has a strike-rate of 36, which means that Yadav picks up a wicket after every 36th delivery, while Ashwin took nearly 61 deliveries for a wicket. Thus, there is a contrast difference and it shows that Kuldeep has been more effective than Ashwin despite bowling less than half the overs than Ashwin in first 15 Tests. Before jumping to any conclusion, it is also important to look at the detailed stats of both players at home and away.
Kuldeep vs Ashwin at home CriteriaSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
Kuldeep YadavSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
R Ashwin Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
TestsSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 11Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 12Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table WicketsSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 65Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 76Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Overs BowledSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 283.1Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 854Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table AverageSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 21.68Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 25.63Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table EconomySelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 3.59Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 2.83Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Strike-rateSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 36.1Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 54.32Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 5w/10wSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 3Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 8/0Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
Key observations Both players have played majority of their career at home and have done exceptionally well. Meanwhile, Kuldeep also surpasses Ashwin's feats at home after 15 Tests as Kuldeep has a better average and also better strike-rate than Ashwin. Ashwin's strike-rate improves at home, but Kuldeep's strike-rate at home is similar to his overall strike-rate. Kuldeep vs Ashwin away CriteriaSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
Kuldeep YadavSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
R Ashwin Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
TestsSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 4Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 3Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table WicketsSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 18Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 9Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Overs BowledSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 106.5Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 168Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table AverageSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 19.55Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 62.78Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table EconomySelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 3.29Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 2.83Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Strike-rateSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 35.6Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 112.00Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 5w/10wSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 2Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 0/0Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
Key observations While Ashwin and Kuldeep boasts a similar home record, but in away conditions, Kuldeep is miles ahead of Ashwin after 15 Tests. Be it wickets, average or strike-rate, Kuldeep Yadav has been more effective than Ashwin for India.
There is a massive difference between the stats as Ashwin had an average of 62.78 and a strike-rate of 112, which forced India to make him sit on the bench in overseas conditions. However, same is not the case with Kuldeep Yadav, who in fact boasts a better away record for India than at home.
Conclusion Based on performance in away conditions, Kuldeep has clear edge over Ashwin and is the better spinner among the two after first 15 Tests for India. However, on home conditions, Kuldeep has effortlessly managed to match Ashwin's legacy.