Shaheen Afridi Vs Mohammad Amir: Statistical Comparison Of Asia Cup Records



Shaheen vs Amir in Asia Cup [Source: AFP Photo]
Shaheen vs Amir in Asia Cup [Source: AFP Photo]

The wait is almost over as the Asia Cup 2025 is set to commence next month, with eight teams competing to be crowned the champions of Asia. India are the defending champions, and will enter the tournament as the favourites. However, if there is any team that can challenge the Men in Blue, then it has to be Pakistan. They wear the unpredictability badge and can upset any team on their day.

For Pakistan to succeed, the form of Shaheen Afridi matters. If the left-arm seamer is at his best, then the Men in Green have a great chance to get their hands on the trophy. Before Shaheen, there was another pressure who was responsible to deliver the goods for Pakistan, and he was Mohammad Amir. The former cricketer had a terrific record when playing in multi-national tournaments, and he used to always deliver the goods.

But, who is the better of  the two?. Does Shaheen has better stats? Or Amir still stands strong. Here is a comparison of their Asia Cup numbers.

Shaheen Afridi vs Mohammad Amir: Overall Asia Cup stats

Criterion
Shaheen Afridi
Mohammad Amir
Matches87
Dismissals
147
Average25.923.57
Economy rate5.404.85
Strike rate28.729.14
  • As the table suggests, Shaheen has pipped Amir when it comes to wicket-taking abilities in the Asia Cup. While Shaheen has 14 wickets in eight matches, Amir only has seven in seven matches, and interestingly, all of his wickets came in the 2016 edition, while he failed to clinch a single scalp in the 2018 Asia Cup.
  • While Shaheen is marginally ahead in terms of strike rates, Amir beats him in terms of economy rate. But Shaheen is the clear winner since he has 7 more wickets, while playing just one game more.

Shaheen Afridi vs Mohammad Amir: Asia Cup ODI stats

Criterion
Shaheen Afridi
Mohammad Amir
Matches83
Dismissals
14
0
Average25.9
N/A
Economy rate5.40
4.66
Strike rate28.7
N/A
  • Shaheen clearly was a better ODI Asia Cup bowler and the stats tell the entire story. Amir played 3 ODI Asia Cup matches and failed to pick up a single wicket.
  • Meanwhile, Shaheen has not played a single Asia Cup T20I game, but his ODI record is impeccable, with 14 wickets to his name. The Eagle, Shaheen has an average of 25, and has clearly been a genuine wicket-taker across any format in Asia Cup. But the same cannot be said about Amir.

Final verdict

Their T20I stats cannot be compared since Shaheen is yet to play a T20I Asia Cup game for Pakistan, but when it comes to the overall record, and the ODI numbers, the current seamer is miles ahead of the former cricketer. He has more wickets, has a better strike rate, and the only area where Amir was marginally ahead was economy. But since a fast bowlers' job is to take wickets, and Shaheen has done that consistently, he becomes the winner.