India vs Pakistan: Decoding Better Probable Playing XIs For Asia Cup 2025



Suryakumar Yadav and Shaheen Shah Afridi [Source: AFP Media]Suryakumar Yadav and Shaheen Shah Afridi [Source: AFP Media]

The Asia Cup is drawing close, and the 2025 edition of the tournament will be played in the T20 format. As the event draws close, even though shrouded by clouds, the face-off between Indian and Pakistan also draws close. 

As the teams prepare themselves to play against each other on the field, we take a look at the probable XIs of them and compare to find which combination looks stronger on paper.

Method

To compare the playing XIs of the two teams, we will use a method where we consider the prime components of the trades. In case of batting - Strike Rate, Average and Boundary Percentage have been considered.

For bowling, Average, Strike Rate and Economy Rate is considered. For all-rounders we have combined the two indices and normalised it.

Batters

India
Batting Index
Pakistan
Batting Index
Abhishek Sharma20.4Saim Ayub7.2
Shubman Gill8.4Fakhar Zaman8.2
Tilak Varma16.7Mohammad Haris9.1
Suryakumar Yadav15.7Hasan Nawaz15.6
Jitesh Sharma4.6Hussain Talat10.2

In case of batting index of the two teams, there are five batters in each side. If we average the values, then we can see that the Indian batters outweigh the Pakistan batters by three points. 

Verdict: Overall efficiency of the Indian batting line-up is better than Pakistan.

Average batting index: India - 13.16, Pakistan - 10.06

All-rounders

India
All-rounder Index
Pakistan
All-rounder Index
Hardik Pandya10.4Mohammad Nawaz10.9
Axar Patel11.2Khushdil Shah9.5
Salman Ali Agha8.9

If we see the two playing XIs we see that Pakistan have one player more in this category. So, in case of the pure total, they have the advantage over India. However, if we consider the average efficiency of each player, the 'Men In Blue' outweigh their neighbours in this case also.

Verdict: In case of the all-rounders too, the efficiency of the Indian team is more than that of the Pakistan playing XI.

Average all-rounder index: India - 10.8, Pakistan - 9.76

Bowlers

India
Bowling Index
Pakistan
Bowling Index
Jasprit Bumrah18.8Shaheen Afridi21
Arshdeep Singh20Haris Rauf27.4
Varun Chakravarthy12.7Sufiyan Muqeem12.9
Kuldeep Yadav27.3

In case of the bowling department, India have one bowler more. The total of bowling index in this case is in favour of the 'Men in Blue'. However, in average Pakistan are better than India in this case.

Verdict: The bowling efficiency of Pakistan is better than that of India.

Average Bowler index: India - 19.70, Pakistan - 20.43

Conclusion

When we see the three departments of the two teams, we can see that India are better in the batting and all-rounder section. However, in case of bowling Pakistan are ahead of India. Since, India have the advantage in two departments, we can say that the probable XI of the 'Men in Blue' are better than that of their arch-rivals.