Hardik Pandya's Test career is a tale of unfulfilled potential [Source: @mufaddal_vohra, @BCCI/x.com]
Some careers feel complete even when they aren’t and then there are some like Hardik Pandya’s, a story left half-written, a firework that fizzled out too soon. In a world where seam-bowling all-rounders are invaluable, India had finally found their diamond in the rough only for it to vanish before it could shine in its full glory.
Hardik Pandya In Tests Was A Dream That Ended Before It Began
Hardik Pandya played just 11 Tests between 2017 and 2018. That’s it. But in that short span, he gave a glimpse of what India had been missing since Kapil Dev hung up his boots.
He wasn’t just a bits-and-pieces player. He was a proper three-gear cricketer. Needed someone to hang in there with the bat? He would do it. Needed a breakthrough with the ball? He would provide it. Needed someone to swing the game in a session? He was that guy, too.
The numbers might not knock your socks off as he averaged 31 with bat and ball but it’s the impact that mattered.
He scored a century in Sri Lanka, took a five-for at Trent Bridge and smashed a counter-attacking 90 in South Africa. Not bad for someone who was still finding his feet in red-ball cricket.
He batted everywhere from No.6 to No.8. He bowled 8-10 overs a day, often giving the main pacers a breather without letting the pressure drop. Even on off days, he offered control, assurance and presence.
Better Than Most Who Tried
India tried to fill the Kapil Dev-sized hole with plenty of names. Irfan Pathan couldn’t settle in. Ajit Agarkar flirted with greatness but couldn’t hold on. Bhuvneshwar Kumar was more of a tailender with a straight bat. Sanjay Bangar? More part-time than all-round.
Even Shardul Thakur, who has pulled rabbits out of the hat on occasion, has a batting average of 19 and a bowling economy close to 4. His magic works in spurts but not in sustained spells. The only one who looked like the real deal? Hardik Pandya.
Then Came The Injury
It all came crashing down in the 2018 Asia Cup. A back injury saw Pandya stretchered off. Not just from the ground but from India’s red-ball future. He never played a Test again. What followed were multiple comeback whispers, but nothing concrete.
India’s Search For Balance Continues
Coming to the present, the balance Pandya brought is still missing. In the ongoing England series, Nitish Reddy and Shardul have been tried. Reddy failed to make it count with both bat and ball. He looked more like a batter who could bowl a bit. Shardul? In and out, leaking runs and unable to seal a spot.
India’s team combination has been a jigsaw puzzle since Pandya’s exit. Play an extra seamer and risk the tail getting exposed. Pick an extra batter and weaken the bowling. Play two spinners abroad and pray the pitch helps. There has been no middle ground. No glue guy. No cheat code like Pandya.
Imagine Pandya Under Gambhir
India now have a head coach in Gautam Gambhir who swears by multi-dimensional players. If only their paths crossed in red-ball cricket, Pandya under Gambhir could’ve been a dream. Someone who backs himself, wears his heart on his sleeve and brings the heat, just the kind of player Gambhir would throw his weight behind.
The Stokes Comparison That Hurts
Ben Stokes is the benchmark. Match-winner, leader, all-format beast. Pandya had that in him too. The aura, the ability, the temperament. But while Stokes has racked up 115 Tests under his belt, Pandya didn’t even get to 15. It’s like watching a blockbuster trailer, only to find out the movie got shelved.
Conclusion
Hardik Pandya remains one of India’s biggest what-ifs in Test cricket.
A player who could have solved so many headaches. A player who brought balance just by walking into the XI. His Test career didn’t crash. It just quietly walked away one day and never returned.
He will continue lighting up white-ball tournaments. He will win games, titles and accolades. But somewhere, in the quiet corners of Indian cricket’s red-ball diary, there will always be a footnote:
“We had him. And we lost him.”