• Home
  • Cricket News
  • Batter Declared Not Out Despite Middle Stump Being Uprooted Image Goes Viral

Batter Declared Not Out Despite Middle Stump Being Uprooted; Image Goes Viral

image-lpzozytiUmpire declared the batter not out as the bails didn't come off [X.com]

In a twist of events that left cricket fans in stitches, a Melbourne club cricket game witnessed a rather comical yet contentious decision by the umpire. Despite the middle wicket being disturbed, the batter was declared "not out" in a bizarre incident where the bails remained mysteriously intact.

Opinions on the umpire's call have flooded social media, with some staunchly defending the decision based on the laws of cricket. According to Law 29 of the MCC's Laws of Cricket, a wicket is considered broken only if a bail is completely removed or a stump is struck out of the ground. 

In this peculiar case, both bails managed to stay put, despite the middle stump facing some disruption, leading to a split opinion among cricket enthusiasts.

Critics argue that the umpires should have been more cautious, suggesting that the stumps and bails were packed too tightly, contributing to this unusual scenario. Thе dеbate hinges on the interpretation of the laws, particularly the definition of a broken wicket.

The MCC's law states, "The disturbance of a bail, whether temporary or not, shall not constitute its complete removal from the top of the stumps." However, if a bail falls and lodges between two stumps, it is deemed a complete removal. This technicality played a crucial role in the recent umpiring decision that has bеcome the talk of the town and the cricketing community.

Interestingly, this is not the first time such an incident has occurred in the game of cricket. In 2017, a batter was declared 'Out' even though the bails remained intact in a similar incident. Jatindeer Singh, playing for Moonee Valley, faced a perplexing situation when he was given out despite the bails not being dislodged.

The image of undisturbed bails in the midst of a disturbed middle stump has gone viral, adding a quirky chapter to the annals of cricketing controversies. As debates continue to unfold, cricket enthusiasts eagerly await the next twist in this unexpected tale of wickets and bails.