Virat Kohli vs Rohit Sharma: Who Will India Miss More During India Tour Of England 2025?

Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma [Source: @katyxkohli17, @BCCI/x.com]

With India's five-Test series against England starting June 20 at Headingley, the team faces an unprecedented challenge: navigating without their two batting stalwarts, Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma, who announced their Test retirements within days of each other in May 2025. This departure marks the end of an era, but which player's absence will hurt India more in English conditions?

Statistical Legacy: The Numbers Tell a Story

Both players leave behind remarkable Test careers, though with stark differences in longevity and consistency.

Virat Kohli vs Rohit Sharma: Career Test Statistics Comparison

Virat Kohli's 123 Tests spanning 14 years produced 9,230 runs at an average of 46.85, making him the fourth-highest run-scorer for India behind Tendulkar, Dravid, and Gavaskar. Rohit's 67 Tests yielded 4,301 runs with 12 hundreds and 18 fifties.

Performance In England

Kohli's England record spans three tours: a dismal 134 runs in 2014, a stellar 593 runs with two centuries in 2018, and a modest 249 runs in 2021. One of Rohit Sharma's two overseas Test century came at The Oval in 2021, scoring 127 against England.

Leadership and Experience Gap

As India's most successful Test captain with 40 wins in 68 matches, Kohli transformed the team's overseas approach and instilled an aggressive winning mentality. Rohit's leadership experience, though limited to recent years in Tests, brought calm and methodical decision-making to the role.

The captaincy void is particularly significant with Shubman Gill taking over a relatively inexperienced squad where only Rishabh Pant and KL Rahul have previous Test experience in England.

The Verdict: Kohli's Absence Hurts More

While both retirements create substantial gaps, India will miss Kohli more for several critical reasons:

Experience and Adaptability: Kohli's extensive England experience, including his 2018 masterclass, demonstrated his ability to adapt to challenging overseas conditions. His technical adjustments and mental fortitude in alien conditions remain unmatched.

Leadership Legacy: Kohli's aggressive captaincy transformed India's overseas mentality, achieving historic wins in Australia and South Africa. His on-field intensity and tactical acumen created a winning culture that Rohit, despite his calm leadership, had less time to fully establish in Tests.

Consistency Across Conditions: With 16 away hundreds compared to Rohit's 2 overseas century, Kohli proved more adaptable to varying conditions. Rohit's impressive home average of 51.73 contrasts sharply with his overseas struggles.

These are big holes to fill, the transition represents an opportunity for new talent. However, replacing Kohli's unique combination of overseas experience, leadership legacy, and proven England performance makes his absence the more significant loss for India's challenging tour ahead.

---

ALSO READ

Shardul Thakur vs Nitish Reddy: Battle for India's Crucial All-Rounder Slot At Leeds

---