Rich Vs Poor In IPL 2025: Players Who Shook Franchise Owners With Highs And Lows

Shreyas Iyer and Rishabh Pant [Source: AP Photos]

The Indian Premier League 2025 witnessed record-breaking auction prices, with Rishabh Pant becoming the most expensive player ever at ₹27 crore. But did these mega-investments pay off? Our comprehensive Return on Investment (ROI) analysis using actual ball-by-ball performance data reveals surprising winners and devastating losses.

Methodology: Performance Value Calculation

Our analysis evaluated the highest-paid players using a weighted scoring system based on actual match data. For batters, we considered runs scored strike rate bonuses/penalties, and milestone achievements . Bowlers were assessed on wickets taken, economy rate efficiency, and bowling averages. Players ruled out due to injury received a 90% performance penalty, reflecting the complete loss of investment.

We established an expected performance benchmark of 40 points per crore invested, then compared actual performance values to determine profit or loss for each franchise.

The Profit Champions (Ranked by Returns)

1. Jasprit Bumrah (MI): +₹9.00 crore profit

Mumbai Indians struck gold with their ₹18 crore investment on their ever dependable, Jasprit Bumrah. Bumrah's 18 wickets in 11 matches with a miserly 6.37 economy rate delivered a phenomenal 50% ROI. His elite bowling despite injury concerns proved that excellence prevails even in the most challenging situations.

2. Heinrich Klaasen (SRH): +₹6.90 crore profit

SRH too a calcualted risk by retaining Heinrich Klassen for ₹23 Crores and it paid great dividends. Heinrich Klaasen's 487 runs at a blistering 172.70 strike rate provided explosive middle-order firepower. Even though SRH were below par throughout the tournament, Klaasen scored consistent runs and came up with a profit of around ₹ 7 Cr. 

3. Shreyas Iyer (PBKS): +₹3.20 crore profit

PBKS's ₹26.75 crore investment in their new captain delivered excellent returns.  Shreyas Iyer's 516 runs in 15 matches at an explosive 170.86 strike rate, including five fifties and a highest score of 97*, proved his leadership and batting prowess. His consistent run scoring combined with his leadership justified the massive investement.

4. Virat Kohli (RCB): +₹2.10 crore profit

The veteran's ₹21 crore investment proved RCB's wisest decision. Virat Kohli's 614 runs across 14 matches, featuring six fifties, provided the reliable anchor RCB needed. His consistency delivered modest but crucial profits.

IPL 2025 ROI Analysis [Source: OneCricket]

The Loss Makers (Ranked by Loss)

1. Venkatesh Iyer (KKR): -₹18.95 crore loss

The season's most devastating financial catastrophe saw KKR's ₹23.75 crore investment become the worst ROI disaster. With only 142 runs in 7 matches at a strike rate of 139.22, Iyer's limited game time and modest performance created the biggest loss among all highest-paid players.

2. Rishabh Pant (LSG): -₹16.20 crore loss

Despite his record ₹27 crore price tag, Rishabh Pant delivered disappointing returns. His meager 269 runs in 13 matches at a pedestrian 133.17 strike rate made LSG's historic investment a major regret, though not the worst performing player.

2. Ruturaj Gaikwad (CSK): -₹16.20 crore loss

CSK's retained captain became their biggest nightmare when injury struck after just five matches. Ruturaj Gaikwad's season-ending injury transformed the ₹18 crore investment into a complete write-off, forcing MS Dhoni's captaincy comeback and derailing campaign strategy.

4. Rashid Khan (GT): -₹5.40 crore loss

GT's decision to retain Rashid Khan for ₹18 crore, backfired significantly. The Afghan spinner failed to leave any sort of impact. His underwhelming season lead to significant loss for the franchise.

5. Axar Patel (DC): -₹4.45 crore loss

DC's highest-paid player at ₹16.50 crore delivered mixed results. While his aggressive batting provided value, his expensive bowling and low wicket tally created a moderate loss for the franchise.

6. Sanju Samson (RR): -₹1.80 crore loss

RR's captain underwhelmed with his ₹18 crore retention. Despite 285 runs in nine matches, Sanju Samson's inconsistent performances and lack of match-winning impact made him a minor but notable loss.

Return On Investment Ranking Table

Team Impact Summary

Conclusion

The IPL 2025 ROI analysis reveals that auction success hinges on performance delivery rather than marquee value. While Jasprit Bumrah's bowling mastery and Heinrich Klaasen's explosive batting proved that specialized excellence pays dividends, Venkatesh Iyer's limited game time became the league's costliest mistake with a devastating ₹18.95 crore loss.

Shreyas Iyer's transformation from expensive buy to profitable captain at PBKS demonstrates how leadership and consistency can justify mega-investments. 

The season's lesson is clear: Teams that prioritize current form and specific role requirements over brand value will continue to dominate the auction battlefield, making data-driven decisions the key to IPL financial success.

---

ALSO READ

5 Players With Most Fifties In T20 Matches On Indian Soil

---