MS Dhoni's Legacy Hurting CSK? Is The Franchise Failing To Plan For Future?

MS Dhoni for CSK [Source: @mufaddal_vohra/x.com]

In the storied history of the Indian Premier League, few figures command the reverence and adoration that MS Dhoni does. The statistics tell a compelling story of a cricketer whose journey with Chennai Super Kings has been nothing short of legendary, with 5,243 runs at an average of 39.13 and a strike rate of 137.47 across 18 seasons. However, as the 2025 season begins, the "Thala" phenomenon presents CSK with a complex challenge that goes beyond numbers.

Table: MS Dhoni's Top 5 Seasons by Run Total

The Evolution of Dhoni's Role

MS Dhoni's impact per ball by batting position [Source: OneCricket]

Analysis of Dhoni's IPL career reveals a fascinating transformation. During CSK's early years (2008-2014), Dhoni typically batted at positions 4-5. This allowed him ample time to build innings, reflected in his impressive run totals: 414 runs (2008), 461 runs (2013), and consistent 300+ run seasons.

However, recent data tells a different story. Since 2024, Dhoni has relinquished captaincy duties, and his batting position has undergone a dramatic shift. Analysis of his recent matches shows he now primarily occupies positions 7-8 in the batting order.

The impact is evident: MS Dhoni faces significantly fewer deliveries at these positions (approximately 13.4 balls at position 7 and just 10.1 balls at position 8) compared to his earlier career where he averaged nearly 19 balls when batting at positions 3-5. This tactical adjustment has altered his contribution from an innings-builder to a specialised finisher.

MS Dhoni Strike Rate vs Batting Position [Source: OneCricket]

The Numbers Behind the Change

The statistics paint a picture of adaptation rather than decline. While Dhoni's total runs have decreased (from 400+ in peak seasons to 161 in 2024), his strike rate has remarkably improved. The 2023 and 2024 seasons saw Dhoni achieve his career-best strike rates of 182.46 and 220.55 respectively—significantly higher than his career average of 137.47.

MS Dhoni batting position over the years [Source: OneCricket]

This shift suggests a deliberate strategic evolution: Dhoni now focuses on maximising impact in minimal deliveries rather than anchoring innings. The data confirms this transition was most pronounced from the 2020 season onward, coinciding with his advancing age and changing team dynamics.

Table: Evolution of Dhoni's Batting Role Over Time

The Dilemma for CSK

Herein lies the dilemma for Chennai Super Kings. Dhoni's immense popularity means every match becomes a celebration of his legacy, with stadiums filled with yellow-clad fans chanting "Dhoni! Dhoni!" regardless of the match situation. This fan obsession, while testament to his impact on the sport, potentially creates challenges for team planning.

CSK must balance honouring their iconic player while preparing for the future. With Dhoni now 43 years old and batting in limited cameo roles, the franchise faces difficult questions: Is continuing to build marketing and team strategy around Dhoni sustainable? Does the emotional attachment to their talisman potentially hamper the development of younger talent who could serve as long-term replacements?

As Chennai Super Kings navigate this transition, their challenge is clear: honour the legacy of their greatest icon while charting a future that ensures the franchise's continued success. For fans, appreciating Dhoni's evolved role may require the same adaptation that their hero has demonstrated throughout his remarkable career.

---

ALSO READ

3 Times MS Dhoni Emerged As CSK's Backbone By Bashing RCB In IPL

---