The Aging 'Thala' Dilemma: Is MS Dhoni CSK's Biggest Problem?

MS Dhoni for CSK [Source: @MSD07NTR9/x.com]

In the high-stakes arena of IPL 2025, Chennai Super Kings find themselves in unfamiliar territory - languishing at the bottom of the points table with just one win from six matches. As the 43-year-old MS Dhoni steps back into the captain's role, questions abound about whether the legendary wicketkeeper-batsman has become the very problem he's trying to solve. With CSK's campaign hanging by a thread, we analyse whether the aging Thala is holding back the Yellow Army or if the issues run deeper.

Numbers Raise Concern

Dhoni's batting statistics tell a story of inconsistency, managing 104 runs from 75 balls at a strike rate of 138.67. His match-by-match performance reveals a rollercoaster:

Crucially, in the KKR match - his first as captain in IPL 2025 - Dhoni maintained his lower-order position at #9 despite the team's batting struggles, raising questions about his willingness to lead from the front.

The Bigger Picture

CSK's struggles extend far beyond Dhoni. Their powerplay bowling economy of 8.75 and death bowling economy of 9.91 reveal fundamental bowling issues. The batting unit's middle-overs run rate of just 6.57 indicates a collective problem rather than an individual one.

The loss of Ruturaj Gaikwad (who batted at #3, not as opener) to an elbow fracture has further destabilized a team already using six different top-order combinations in six matches. Rachin Ravindra's underperformance (strike rate 123.14) as opener has compounded these problems.

The Verdict

While Dhoni's age and declining batting prowess are factors, they aren't CSK's primary concern. The more significant issues are structural: bowling indiscipline across all phases, batting collapses in the middle overs, and over-reliance on a top order that's now missing its anchor in Gaikwad.

Dhoni's reluctance to promote himself up the order - even after taking over captaincy - suggests he recognises his limitations. Yet, ironically, his batting position (averaging #7.5) means he rarely gets enough opportunity to influence match outcomes substantially.

The most telling statistic: In matches where MS Dhoni performed brilliantly (SR>185), CSK still lost, indicating that even at his best, the 43-year-old can no longer be the saviour. CSK's problems are systemic, with Dhoni now resembling a veteran firefighter with a bucket of water facing a forest fire that requires much more than his aging arms can deliver.

---

ALSO READ

3 Embarrassing Records Scripted By CSK After Shocking Defeat vs KKR

---