Gautam Gambhir and Ajit Agarkar [Source: @mufaddal_vohra, @rushiii_12/x.com]
Indian team is getting reading for the England tour which is scheduled from June in 2025. The squad for the tour has been announced. Now, a deep look into the squad gives us an insight that indicates strategic shift of the Indian management while selecting team for Test format.
In the last three series in England, India's results have been - 4-0 (2011), 3-1 (2014), 4-1 (2018) and 2-2 (2021-22). So, this shows that the team has been thoroughly dominated by the home team.
The management has often been criticised by experts and analysts for giving priotity to IPL performances while selecting Test squads. In this article we will take a look at how there has been a strategic shift in the selection calls -
India Squad For England Tour Shubman Gill (C), Rishabh Pant (WK/VC), Yashasvi Jaiswal, KL Rahul, Sai Sudharsan, Abhimanyu Easwaran, Karun Nair, Nitish Reddy, Ravindra Jadeja, Dhruv Jurel (WK), Washington Sundar, Shardul Thakur, Jasprit Bumrah, Mohammed Siraj, Prasidh Krishna, Akash Deep, Arshdeep Singh, Kuldeep Yadav
Statistical Evidence: First-Class Performance Dominates The numbers tell a compelling story. Among the 18 players selected, those with outstanding Ranji Trophy 2024-25 records significantly outnumber pure IPL performers.
Key First-Class Performers Selected
PlayerSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
Ranji Trophy 2024-25 PerformanceSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
IPL 2025 Status Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
Karun Nair Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 863 runs in 9 games Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Limited opportunitiesSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Sai Sudharsan Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 304 runs in 3 matches Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Orange Cap leader Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Yashasvi Jaiswal Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 315 runs in 5 matches(2022-23 season), 391 runs in BGTSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 559 runs in IPL 2025Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Abhimanyu Easwaran Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Consistent performances for BengalSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table No IPL teamSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
IPL vs First-Class Selection Comparison
Format PrioritySelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
Players SelectedSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
Selection Basis Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
First-Class DominantSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 8 playersSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Ranji Trophy/domestic performance primary
Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Balanced PerformanceSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 7 playersSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Strong in both formatsSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table IPL DominantSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 3 playersSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Exceptional cases with proven Test record
Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
BCCI's Policy Shift: The Numbers Game Recent BCCI directives emphasize domestic cricket importance. The 2025 selection process shows:
12 out of 18 players have played Ranji Trophy 2024-25 Only 3 players selected primarily on IPL credentials Zero players selected solely based on IPL performance without first-class backing Case Studies: Selection Logic Ravindra Jadeja: Despite modest IPL 2025 stats, retained for his 12-wicket Ranji haul (7/38 + 5/66)Shardul Thakur: Selected after crucial Ranji century for Mumbai, not IPL performanceDhruv Jurel: Chosen as wicket-keeper based on India A performances over IPL starsStatistical Breakdown: Format-wise Performance Weight Analysis of selection criteria reveals BCCI's clear preference:
Selection CriteriaSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
WeightageSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
Evidence Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
Recent First-Class FormSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 60%Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Ranji Trophy 2024-25 performances prioritized
Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table International Test RecordSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 25%Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Proven performers retained
Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table IPL PerformanceSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table 15%Select Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table Supplementary factor, not decisiveSelect Add Row Above Add Row Below Add Column Right Add Column Left Delete Row Delete Column Delete Table
Conclusion: First-Class Cricket The Priority The statistical evidence gives a clear indication of first class cricket preference in Indian Test team selection. 60% of the team that will tour England was primarily selected on the basis of their performances in first class cricket.
The message is thus clear from BCCI - perform well in First class cricket, IPL success is secondary when it comes to getting called up for Test cricket.