• Home
  • Cricket News
  • Why Is Rahane Always Asked To Prove Himself Why Are Indians So Unfair To Him

Why is Rahane always asked to prove himself? Why are Indians so unfair to him?


One of the biggest problems of with Indian cricket community is its inability to distinguish between formats. This is most evident in how performances in Indian Premier League (IPL) are often considered sound basis to rate a player's abilities in the longer format. 

Also, not looking at different formats separately leads to incorrect assumptions about form. One player who is constantly described as playing for his career or under pressure to prove himself again is Ajinkya Rahane. Anyone who only looks at his Test performances would be stunned to see how unfairly he is tagged as 'out of form' even in the longest format of the game. 

So much has been said and written about the 'form' of Rahane coming into this series. That is the height of absurdity. If one looks at the performances of Rahane in Test cricket, he would know that the Mumbai batsman has been among the most consistent in the Indian team and is actually a cornerstone of the team's batting. 

But this is where the short-sightedness of Indian fans and critics comes into play. Just because he didn't have a good IPL, Rahane was dubbed as being 'out of form.' Now, what in the world does a T20 league have to do with Test cricket. If IPL performances be the parameter for judging a player's form in Tests, Indian should drop Pujara since he doesn't even get into an IPL XI. 

Now, let's look at Rahane's performances in the last few years. Yes, he didn't get runs in the two Tests against New Zealand, India's last Test series. But guess what, neither did Virat Kohli. In fact, in the four innings that India played in that series, the highest score by an Indian was 58 - by Mayank Agarwal in the second innings of the first Test. In the first innings of that match, Rahane was the top scorer for India with 46. 

Now let's keep going backwards. Before that series, India played Bangladesh at home in two Tests. India had just two innings to bat in the two matches. Rahane scored 86 and 51 in his two innings. 

Before that, India played South Africa in three Tests at home. Rahane scored 215 runs in that series with an average of over 72, including one century and one half-century. Before that, in West Indies, Rahane scored 271 runs at an average of 102 with one hundred and two fifties, in the two-match series.  

Now, even before the series in West Indies, Rahane was deemed to be 'under pressure.' Why was that? Let's look at his performances in Test matches before that tour. 

In India's famous series win in Australia, Rahane wasn't among the top scorers. Still, he scored half-centuries in the first two Tests - He didn't get runs in the remaining two matches, which included just three innings, but is that enough to question his place in the team. 

Prior to the tour of Australia, Rahane had scored 87 in the first innings of the only Test India won in England, forming a partnership with Virat Kohli that set up India's victory. Prior to that, in South Africa, Ravi Shastri and Virat Kohli chose Rohit Sharma ahead of Rahane for the first two Tests because Rohit has more 'intent' - the word that Shastri-Kohli duo are obsessed with. 

Rohit failed in both those matches and then, Rahane played in the third Test, played on a most dangerous seamer-friendly pitch. In India's vital second-innings, he top-scored with 48, helping India gain a big win. 

Let's also not forget his great overall record and previous achievements. He was India's leading scorer in the 2014 series in England, and set up India's improbable win on a green-top at Lord's with a magnificent hundred. He scored runs in Australia, South Africa, New Zealand, and West Indies on his first tours to those countries, in the period 2013-16. Is there anything more needed to show how good he is?

A player with such a record ought to be backed even when he's had a lean series, rather than judged to be 'playing for his place.' More importantly, Rahane's form since India's tour of West Indies has been extremely good. Yet, because he didn't do well in a T20 league, he was judged to be 'under pressure.' Such nonsense must cease immediately. 


Powered by Froala Editor

Powered by Froala Editor

Powered by Froala Editor

Discover more
Top Stories
news

New Zealand seal advantage by grinding Pakistan further on day 2

More pain and struggle was in store for Pakistan on day 2 of the first Test at Mount Maunganui as the ever-efficient BJ Watling led his team past the score of 400 in their first innings. The Kiwis ended up with a score of 431. Pakistan, in reply, were 30/1 when the day's play ended. In the first session, the spotlight was on Kane Williamson who was batting on 94 overnight. His masterful display of discipline and determination was chiefly responsible for getting his team in a good position. He duly brought up his hundred with a silky smooth off drive - his 23rd century in Tests, just three less than Steve Smith and four less than Virat Kohli. The other overnight batsman Henry Nicholls had also reached a milestone, of his fifty earlier. The two batsman were now looking very comfortable on a pitch that seemed to have lost most of its venom. A sharp rising delivery from Naseem Shah ended Nicholls' vigil as the ball took the edge, to be taken behind the stumps. But Williamson looked at his elegant best, reeling off those gracious drives through the off side that distinguish his batting. It took a brilliant delivery from Yasir Shah to end Williamson's knock at his personal score of 129. A delivery on a good length pitched and turned to take the edge of the New Zealand captain's bat, which was taken very low at first slip. At 281/5, Pakistan would have fancied their chances of restricting the home side to a manageable total. Unfortunately for them, BJ Watling, the defiant, nuggety wicketkeeper-batsman again stood like a fort and didn't let the visitors get any more breakthroughs. He showed the solid technique and determination that his captain possesses to carve useful partnerships with Mitchell Santner first and Kyle Jamieson later. In this period, Pakistan surprisingly didn't use their most reliable bowler Mohamamd Abbas. Yasir was used and bowled well, but on a pitch that didn't give much help. Eventually, Faheem removed Santner with a wide delivery that the all-rounder tried to play, to be caught by the wicketkeeper. Jamieson, who was playing a highly irritating innings for Pakistan was dismissed by a good delivery by Abbas that bounced just a bit extra on a very tight off-stump line. His 32 though, formed part of an invaluable 66-run stand for the seventh wicket. After the tea break, Yasir ended the innings of Tim Southee. The pacer looked on edge against Yasir throughout his innings and was bowled by the leggie for a duck. Watling's innings ended at the score of 73 when he tried to guide a short ball from Shaheen Afridi over the slip cordon but was caught superbly by a diving Yasir at gully. Shaheen now wanted his fifth but Neil Wagner and Trent Boult kept surviving his deliveries in the most ungainly manner. Eventually, it was Yasir who got the final wicket when an attempted slog sweep by him got the top edge that was taken by the midwicket fielder. Shaheen's 4/109 were the best figures of the innings while Yasir's 3/113 were the second best. Faheem, Naseem, and Abbas got one each. When Pakistan started their innings, the focus was on Tim Southee as he is just four wickets short of becoming only the third New Zealander to get 300 Test wickets. However, openers Shan Masood and Abid Ali looked more than capable of taking on the famed new-ball duo of Southee and Boult. Abid, especially, played some brilliant shots. Masood though, was very unlucky to be dismissed when a delivery down the leg side was nicked by him to the wicketkeeper. Pakistan ended the day on 30/1 with Abid on 19 and night-watchman Abbas not having opened his account.

news

Heat vs Hurricanes: James Bazley handles nerve to take Heat to their first win this season

James Bazley, the underrated all-rounder proved his worth as he took the Heat to their first-ever victory in the Big Bash 2020-21. The Heat chased a modest target of 149 with a lot of difficulties, winning the game by only four wickets, even after being 73-0 at one stage. With this win, the Brisbane-based team opened its account in the tournament. The fightback Cruising to victory at one stage with 73-0 in just six overs, Heat were pulled back to 102-6 in 11 overs with all established batsmen gone and two new guys in wicket-keeper batsman Jimmy Pierson and Bazley at the crease. It was then that the two put on an unbeaten 50 run stand treading on caution and mixing it up with some aggression as and when required. It was this partnership that broke the Heat’s three-match winless run. A D'Arcy Short special...but with the ball Known for his big-hitting with the bat, it was the Hurricanes’ part-time bowler D’Arcy Short who brought the team back into the game after an early onslaught by the Heat openers. The left-arm chinaman put in his best-ever bowling effort picking up four crucial wickets of Sam Heazlett, Dan Lawrence, Tom Cooper, and Lewis Gregory. He took the wickets within a span of 27 balls in total, breaking the Heat back. However after his quota of four overs was completed, which he finished at 4-18-3, the others couldn’t continue the pressure he had created, resulting in Bazley and Pierson taking control of the game. The Heat storm It was a storming start to the chase by the Heat openers giving almost no chance for the Hurricanes even to blink an eye and think of a plan. After scoring seven of the first over by James Faulkner, Heazlett and Max Bryant went berserk after the Hobart bowling. They fetched a total of 66 runs in the next five overs, giving ultimate joy to the people present at the Gabba. Hurricanes never got going Earlier in the day, Heat won the toss and invited the visitors to bat first. However, a star studded Hurricanes batting lineup couldn’t live up to its expectations as one start after the other failed to shine. A start-stop inning never got on the track and it was thanks to a 20 ball 35 runs stand for the eighth wicket between Faulkner and Wil Parker that got Hurricanes to a somewhat fighting total of 148 in 20 overs. Lewis Gregory was the game changer with the ball for the Heat picking up two crucial wickets of Dawid Malan and Peter Handscomb off two consecutive deliveries. Before that, he had already removed a dangerous-looking Short. The Somerset all-rounder finished his spell at 3-22 from four overs. What's Next? While this win has given the Heat some confidence, they would like to take it along to their next game when they play the Hurricanes in the reverse leg at the same venue on Wednesday 30th December. The Canes on the other hand would look to bounce back from this defeat and get back to winning ways before their position in the top half of the table comes under any threat.

news

Match Preview: Winless Scorchers up against imperfect Strikers in key contest

Perth Scorchers are looking to finally get off the mark in the ongoing 10th season of the Big Bash League (BBL). They will have another opportunity when they take on Adelaide Strikers on Monday. The Strikers won their last match by the barest of margins. Their performances have been inconsistent with the bowling department showing more efficiency than the batting one. They too are in need of another victory as their current place in the points table - fifth - isn't satisfactory. Strikers Look to Strike Again For the Strikers, the biggest question going into the game against Scorchers is the availability of their ace bowler Rashid Khan. After two relatively unimpressive performances, Rashid came into his own in the last match and showed why he is the premier leg-spinner in the world. However, he then sustained an injury which isn't as bad as feared but still bad enough to cloud the chances of his participation in the game on Monday. He has been kept in the squad and would undergo a fitness test before the match. Luckily for Strikers, Danny Briggs has also found form. His performance in the last match almost overshadowed of the more high-profile tweaker in his team. His tight line and length and ability to bowl with the new ball would come in handy. Among pacers, Peter Siddle is in really good form and is bowling the yorkers really well. Wes Agar too, looks in good rhythm. The batting, though, needs to pick up. Alex Carey and Jack Weatherald are the only two batsmen in the team to have got half-centuries so far in the tournament. There will be pressure on other batters to justify their place in the team. Scorchers Seek First Win On paper, Perth Scorchers' bowling attack looks very competent. However, they haven't produced an impressive performance so far and there hasn't also been individual efforts worth taking note of. What is most disappointing is the fact that Fawad Ahmed, the leg-spinner, hasn't got going. Leg-spinners have emerged as leading match winnners in this format, especially in Big Bash. Fawad has to step up. The batting looks very capable. Colin Munro and Mitchell Marsh have looked in good touch. The New Zealander is a very good striker of the cricket ball and his timing seemed perfect in the previous matches. Marsh too scored a good fifty in the last game. On top of that, Ashton Turner too got some lusty hits under his belt. These three men would lead the batting charge but more would be required from the rest of the batting line-up. Strikers vs Scorchers: Match Details Venue: Adelaide Oval, Adelaide Date and Time: December 28, 1:45 PM IST, 7:15 PM Local, 8:15 AM GMT Broadcaster: Sony Sports Network, Sony LIV Pitch Report This will be the first match of the season at Adelaide. So, the pitch would be a bit of a mystery. However, traditionally, the strip on this ground is flat and and helps spinners a bit. This would bring the tweakers in both sides in play. Weather and Toss A cool evening awaits both the teams for their match on Monday. No clouds or rain are expected and the temperature is expected to fall below 15 degrees. Since no overcasat conditions are expected, the toss would not be a big factor. It usually isn't anyway in T20 matches. Probable XIs Strikers: Phil Salt, Jake Weatherald, Matt Renshaw, Jonathan Wells, Matthew Short, Harry Nielsen (Wk), Rashid Khan (if fit), Daniel Worrall, Danny Briggs, Peter Siddle (C), Wes Agar Scorchers: Josh Inglis (Wk), Colin Munro, Joe Clarke, Mitchell Marsh, Ashton Turner (C), Cameron Bancroft, Jhye Richardson, Aaron Hardie, Andrew Tye, Jason Behrendorff, Fawad Ahmed

news

Will be accused of backing Mumbaikar if I praise Rahane's captaincy: Sunil Gavaskar

Former Indian opener Sunil Gavaskar was slightly impressed with the tactics of the Indian team under the captaincy of Ajinkya Rahane but said that he would refrain from calling him as a great captain as he could be accused of bias in the favour of a Mumbaikar. He also said that Rahane was very early in his captaincy days and that it would be premature to judge his captaincy credentials. “Let’s not jump into conclusions too quickly. If I say that his captaincy is outstanding, then again, I will be accused of backing a Mumbai boy and all kinds of things will happen. So I don’t want to get into that because these are early days,” Gavaskar said on Sony Sports Network from Australia. However, he did not hold back from looking back on what he had observed in the only two Test matches he had captained the side before. He said that the field placements he had set for Marnus Labuscgange highlighted the Rahane’s reading of the game, but, it was also down to the bowler to execute those plans, otherwise Rahane would not be looking like the captain he appears now. “From what I have seen in the last 2 Tests he captained and the one-day matches he captained, he has got a great sense of where the fielders should be kept,” Gavaskar said. “Having said that, it’s very important for the bowlers to bowl to their field. If the bowlers bowl to the field, as they did today, then the captain looks very good.” India have secured a lead of 82 runs at the end of the second day’s play at the MCG on the back of Ajinkya Rahane’s century and resistance from Ravindra Jadeja.