• Home
  • Cricket News
  • T20 World Cup Former Selectors Question Chetan Sharma Over Selection Of Half Fit Hardik Pandya

T20 World Cup | Former selectors question Chetan Sharma over selection of 'half-fit' Hardik Pandya

As India have suffered two heavy defeats in the ongoing T20 World Cup and are staring at elimination without making it to the semi-finals, the battle lines are being drawn by former cricketers and analysts over what went wrong for Virat Kohli’s men in the tournament.

While failure with the bat and lack of penetration with the ball have been emphasised in nuanced analyses, personnel have also been under stern scanners.

One of the biggest talking points before the selection of India’s squad for the tournament and also during the tournament has been the fitness and form of Hardik Pandya. Pandya did not bowl in the Indian Premier League and simultaneously lost form with the bat from the first phase of the tournament.

Former national selector Sarandeep Singh has now questioned the claims made by the current chairman of the selection committee Chetan Sharma in which he had said that Pandya was fit and would be bowling a full quota of overs in the T20 World cup.

He questioned the lack of transparency from the current selection committee and said that during his tenure, players’ availability and fitness were made public appropriately which he says has not happened in this case.

He said that the all-rounder has found himself in a needless controversy and that it’s Chetan Sharma’s job to explain what happened to the squad and why he was picked without a full assessment of his injury and availability with the ball.

“Hardik Pandya’s fitness issues are being talked about for a while now, but why don’t you ask the selection committee about this? We used to answer all questions during our tenure – if someone was unfit or anything – everything used to be open. But why isn’t it the same anymore? Chetan Sharma addressed the media just once, and he spoke something strange and walked away,” Sarandeep Singh said to Sportskeeda.

"When the chairman of the selection committee said he’s fully fit and he will bowl in the World Cup, so the chairman needs to be questioned now where is the fitness. He needs to say something – he is injured, he is not able to bowl, something. It’s unfair on Hardik as well, a quality player is stuck in controversy for no fault of his. If the injury is there, it’s okay, can’t do much about it.”

Another former selector, Sandeep Patil, who was the chief national selector before the selection committee comprising of Sarandeep Singh, had questioned Chetan Sharma on similar lines. He had also fixed the responsibility on the head coach Ravi Shastri and skipper Virat Kohli for playing Pandya in the playing XI.

“His (Pandya) selection in the XI is up to the captain and the coach, and only the BCCI will know about it. But basically, if a player is not fit, then it comes to the selectors. If he didn’t bowl in the entire IPL, the selectors should have taken a call. They should have asked for a fitness test before including him in the team for the World Cup,” Patil had said to Times of India.

 

Discover more
Top Stories
news

Ashes 2021-22 | Joe Root takes inspiration from India's Gabba heroics to turn the heat on Australia

As the days of the upcoming Ashes series in Australia draw closer, the England Test skipper is looking up to India’s superlative win at the Gabba to come with full force and a fearless approach to stand up to Australia. Before that Test loss to India, Australia had not lost the longest format of the game at the venue for decades and even the 2010-11 Ashes series, where the three lions emerged victoriously, they could come as far as drawing the Test. Root emphasized the need for his teammates to win crucial moments of the game and carry on with earned momentum for a long period of time to turn the tables on the hosts Australia. “Look at that India team that won at the Gabba. They were a long way from their first-choice XI but they had no fear, they stood up to Australia and won crucial parts of that Test. It will give every player in our squad a huge amount of confidence and just plant a little bit of doubt in Australia’s mind having to go back there and play again for the first time against us, what with it being such a stronghold for them for such a long period of time. We now know that it’s not,” Root said to The Guardian in an interview. Root was also delighted to see one of his biggest match-winner and deputy Ben Stokes regaining a frame of mind to come back to the Test squad or the big series. Root reiterated his already made public stand that Stokes was given full time and space to consider himself fit, both physically and mentally and that the decision to take that “indefinite break” and now the return was taken solely by him. “I’d got an inkling,” Root says. “I’d had some good conversations with Ben over the period while he’s not been playing. It was just such a joy to hear him speak, you could almost hear his smile, if that makes sense, down the phone. You could tell he was so much happier within himself. Just the fact he feels he’s in a place where he’s ready to play cricket again is the most exciting thing,” Root added. “We made it very clear to Ben, it’s got to be right for you. You have to be in the right space to go and play, physically and mentally. One thing about Ben, he’s very honest, he won’t shirk any difficult conversations and he’s been true to that through the whole thing. We have been through a lot on and off the field. To see him now back in a place where he is able to enjoy his cricket again and feel more himself, that’s the best part of the whole thing. It’s just really exciting.” Joe Root has not had a Test hundred in Australia but he is going there this time on the back of masterful centuries and plenty of runs under his belt and he will back himself to break that batting curse in Australia this time. The first Test of the Ashes series will start on December 09 at the Gabba.

news

Yorkshire concedes Azeem Rafiq was 'degraded' but downplay slurs as 'friendly, good-natured banter'

The Yorkshire County Cricket Club conceded that Azeem Rafiq was “ offended, degraded or humiliated and that this amounted to harassment” while his time with the county and said that he was subjected to situations "capable of creating an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment” in the dressing room. However, they dismissed one player regularly calling Azeem Rafiq using the term 'P**i' as a “friendly, good-natured banter” between two players in its report of the investigation into racism allegations levied by the leg-spinner, ESPNcricinfo reported. The issue goes deeper though as ESPNcricinfo reports that player admitting to also saying stuff like "don't talk to him [Rafiq], he's a P**i", asking "is that your uncle?" when they saw bearded Asian men and saying "does your dad own those?" in reference to corner shops, to other teammates of him and Rafiq. The county also put the onus on Rafiq and said that he should have taken those words as banter and should not have gotten offended with those “friendly banter”. They said that he was “expected to take such comments in the spirit in which they were intended (i.e. good natured banter between friends)… [so] it was not reasonable for Azeem to have been offended by [the other player] directing equally offensive or derogatory comments back at him in the same spirit of friendly banter." The report did not divulge the identity of the person causing that offence to Rafiq and also suggested that the player was unaware of the impact those words had left on Rafiq, who reportedly broke down in tears while recalling those memories.

news

T20 World Cup | Virat Kohli rues playing with fearful approach after loss against New Zealand

India suffered another drubbing in the ongoingT20 World Cup and Virat Kohli has pinned the blame on lack of aggression and intensity from both the batsmen and bowlers. Calling the flow of the game against New Zealand “bizarre”, Kohli said that batsmen were fearful at the start and they could not brave putting their wickets at stake in the optimism of success. He said that Indian players were lacklustre in their body language and New Zealand came with the right attitude and intensive frame of mind to put pressure on them from the rod go. "Quite bizarre. To be very honest and brutal up front, I don't think we were brave enough with bat or ball," Kohli told the host broadcaster during the post-match presentation. "With the ball, I mean, obviously we didn't have much to play with, but we were just not brave enough with our body language when we entered the field, and New Zealand had better intensity, better body language, and they created pressure on us from the first over onwards, really, and continued that through the innings. "Every time we felt like we want to take a chance [while batting], we lost a wicket. That happens in T20 cricket, but that's most probably or most often the result of that little bit of hesitation with the bat when you feel like should you go for the shot or not." India are languishing at the brink of elimination from the tournament after losing heavily to both the Blackcaps and Pakistan. The game against New Zealand was a virtual quarter-final for the men in blue and it was telling on their faces that they feared losing the game. KL Rahul and Rohit Sharma was defensive in their approach and allowed bowlers to continue bowling with their strengths. However, Kohli said that the fear of occasion can’t be an excuse to hide lack of execution on the field and outlined that every player who seeks success at the highest level must learn to live with the pressure that playing for India brings with it. "When you play for the Indian cricket team, you obviously have a lot of expectations, everyone knows that - not only from the fans but from the players themselves," he said. "Wherever we play, we are watched, people come to the stadiums to support us, so there's always going to be more with our games, that's always been the case, and we've embraced it over the years, and everyone who plays for the Indian team obviously has to embrace that as well, and learn how to cope with it. "And when you cope with that as a team, you tend to overcome that pressure and those tough situations. And we haven't, in these two games, and that's why we haven't won." He said that players need to disconnect from what is being talked about and what is at stake while on the field while weighing on that there is plenty of time left in the tournament and that Team India are yet not out of the tournament. "So I think you have to disconnect from that a little bit and just back ourselves out there and take pride in performing for the team. As long as individuals are looking to do that, I think we'll be fine. There's a lot of cricket to play in this tournament, something that we all must look forward to, and certainly, the team must look forward to, and go out with a positive frame of mind." India have their three Super 12 games remaining against Namibia, Afghanistan and Scotland and they have to win all of them with a handsome margin and while also hoping for an Afghanistan win over New Zealand to make it to the semi-finals.