Cricket Australia's head of cricket operations and scheduling, Peter Roach has said that the statement made by former Australian skipper Gregg Chappell about the structure of the domestic cricket does not reflect the entire picture about the health of the game in the country.
Although he conceded that there are improvements to be desired and it should be considered for change with a period of time. He added that even English domestic cricket attracts a lot of criticism and hence no system is absolutely perfect to be modelled.
“Like anyone, I enjoy thinking about whether there's a better way to be doing what we're doing. I think we'd be naïve to think our structure today, which is roughly the same as it was 10 years ago … is going to be right forever. Is it right today? There's lots of different opinions,” Roach told cricket.com.au.
“England's system has from time to time been criticised for too many counties and playing too much, but maybe at the moment that system is working more effectively than ours and we need to take a look at that and see if there are things we can learn."
Roach cited the logistical challenges to the plans proposed by Chappell which suggested that Australia A sides should be playing more matches home and abroad. He said that organising more and more A games can’t sustain without a sound domestic structure and hence it can work only as a ‘conjunction with domestic cricket'.
"Everyone sees the merit in a strong and vibrant 'A' series program that works in conjunction with a strong domestic program," he said. "Sometimes a reason for playing a lot of 'A' series is because you don't believe your domestic products are strong enough,” Roach added.
Chapell had also suggested organising the Sheffield Shield a bit early in the calendar so that it finishes well before the start of the Big Bash League. Roach, however, suggested that shifting the dates of the four-day competition will deny players the opportunity to play overseas such as in the Indian Premier League and County Championship.
“We need to balance our own thinking with the opportunities that are created overseas for players. We've got the IPL and we've got the Hundred among others, we've got county cricket, which has forever and a day proved a great learning tool for Australian cricketers,” Roach said.
“So if we started to move our season, it does come with ramifications in terms of what we can allow our players to go and experience, and it also shortens pre-seasons which are times when players can actively engage in improvements to their game, so there are some things to weigh up.”
“At the moment we've got Marnus Labuschagne, Travis Head and Marcus Harris, three of our top batsmen, playing county cricket. If you extend the Shield season, do they still get that opportunity?”
"They're some of the things we just need to work through. It looks good with the blinkers on, but does it actually work with some of the other opportunities?” Roach concluded.